RRR: Dispute/arbitration
1147
year: 1184
initiator: Dominicus acontantus de confinio sancti basilii
recipient: Iacobus Dandulus de confinio sancte luce
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Oct. 1-31. Acre. Dominicus da mulino de confinio sancti gervasii and Iohanis fusculo de confinio sancte crucis record that, in their presence and in that of Manasses badovarius legatus ducis Venetorum, Dominicus acontantus de confinio sancti basilii settled a dispute with Iacobus Dandulus de confinio sancte luce over the expenses of Dominicus acontantus in relation to [the church of] St Mark of Tyre. Signatories: Dominicus da molino; Iohanis fusculo. The charter was drawn up by Stephanus fuscari presbyter et notarius.
Oct. 1-31. Acre. Dominicus da mulino de confinio sancti gervasii and Iohanis fusculo de confinio sancte crucis record that, in their presence and in that of Manasses badovarius legatus ducis Venetorum, Dominicus acontantus de confinio sancti basilii settled a dispute with Iacobus Dandulus de... more
sources: Baracchi, ‘Le Carte’, p. 338, no. 68 (RRH no. 639)
RRR: Dispute/arbitration
1281
year: 1190
initiator: Pope Clement III
recipient: Archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the Venetian church of St Mark in Tyre
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Aug 11. Lateran. Pope Clement III commissions A[delardus] Ueronensis Romane ecclesie cardinalis, [Monaldus] Fanensis episcopus and [Bonifacius] abbas Nonantulanus to be judge delegates in a dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the Venetian church of St Mark in Tyre about that church’s rights in the Venetian third of Tyre. The rights that are claimed include the parochial ones of baptisms, hearing confessions, burials in the Venetian third of the city cemetery of St Michael, with its entrance from the Venetian section of the city, tithes, schools, marriages, the purification of women and the possession of spolia. The case had arisen in the pontificate of Alexander III and had been heard in the Lateran by Cardinals Teodinus and Hugo, but without resolution.
Aug 11. Lateran. Pope Clement III commissions A[delardus] Ueronensis Romane ecclesie cardinalis, [Monaldus] Fanensis episcopus and [Bonifacius] abbas Nonantulanus to be judge delegates in a dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the Venetian church of St Mark in Tyre about that... more
sources: Hiestand, PK pp. 337-9, no. 161
RRR: Dispute/arbitration
1374
year: 1196
initiator: Pope Celestine III
recipient: Archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the Venetian church of St Mark in Tyre
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Aug. 5, Lateran. Pope Celestine III appoints the archbishop of Nazareth and the bishop of Bethlehem judges delegate in a dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the [Venetian] church of St Mark in Tyre over that church’s parochial rights in the Venetian third part of Tyre. These had been confirmed for the time being, while the Holy Land was not recovered, by Pope Clement III, who had authorized the archbishops of Caesarea and Nazareth and the prior of the Holy Sepulchre to settle the matter. The rights of the church of St Mark were still being challenged by the archbishop of Tyre.
Aug. 5, Lateran. Pope Celestine III appoints the archbishop of Nazareth and the bishop of Bethlehem judges delegate in a dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the [Venetian] church of St Mark in Tyre over that church’s parochial rights in the Venetian third part of Tyre. These... more
sources: Hiestand, PK, pp. 355-7, no. 175 (RRH no. 730)
RRR: Council/ruling decisions/legislation
1468
year: 1200
initiator: Pope Innocent III
recipient: Patriarch of Jerusalem and the archbishop of Caesarea
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Apr. 5. Lateran. Pope Innocent III writes to the patriarch of Jerusalem and the archbishop of Caesarea. He describes how the bishop of Paphos came into his presence, bringing the sentence delivered by the [judge delegates], the bishops of Acre, Tiberias and Beirut, in the case between the archbishop of Tyre and the plebanus of the church of St Mark [in Tyre]. The bishops had followed the papal mandate in demanding that the parties appear before them, but the plebanus had refused to accept the papal mandate or appear before them, appealing instead directly to the Holy See. The bishops visited Tyre, heard testimony and excommunicated the plebanus, restoring his church to the parochial jurisdiction of the archbishop. But representatives of the doge of Venice informed the pope that the Venetians had at the time of the conquest been granted one third of Tyre and that the church of St Mark in Tyre had had parochial rights for a long time. They present letters from Popes Clement III and Celestine III in support of their argument. It was pointed out, moreover, that two of the judge delegates were suffragans of Tyre and therefore biased. Innocent quashes the judgement of the bishops and orders the archbishop of Tyre to restore its rights to the church. The patriarch and archbishop should have this decision published in Tyre.
Apr. 5. Lateran. Pope Innocent III writes to the patriarch of Jerusalem and the archbishop of Caesarea. He describes how the bishop of Paphos came into his presence, bringing the sentence delivered by the [judge delegates], the bishops of Acre, Tiberias and Beirut, in the case between the... more
sources: Tafel and Thomas, Urkunden 1:281-6, no. 87; Decretal 2.6.2, ‘Liber Extra’, cols. 259-60 (RRH no. 770)
RRR: Council/ruling decisions/legislation
1515
year: 1203
initiator: Pope Innocent III
recipient: Canons of Tyre
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: May 30. Lateran. Pope Innocent III informs the canons of Tyre that the plebanus [of the Venetian church of St Mark] has complained about them. The church of St Mark in the Venetian third part of Tyre had been granted full parochial rights [in baptismo, penitentia, sepulturis, decimationibus, benedicendia nubentibus, tenendis scolis et mulieribus] by Popes Clement III and Celestine III until the province of Jerusalem would be restored to the Christians. Innocent himself had reversed the sentence, but had ordered the archbishop of Tyre to do nothing until the papal legates arrived. He has heard how since the death of the archbishop the patriarch of Jerusalem and the canons of Tyre have challenged the position of the plebanus. Innocent orders them to desist until the legates, Cardinal Soffred of St Praxedis and Cardinal Peter of St Marcellus, arrive.
May 30. Lateran. Pope Innocent III informs the canons of Tyre that the plebanus [of the Venetian church of St Mark] has complained about them. The church of St Mark in the Venetian third part of Tyre had been granted full parochial rights [in baptismo, penitentia, sepulturis, decimationibus,... more
sources: Tafel and Thomas, Urkunden 1:425-426, no. 108 (RRH no. 791)
RRR: Council/ruling decisions/legislation
1574
year: 1206
initiator: Pope Innocent III
recipient: Archbishop of Tyre
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Aug. 3. Ferentino. Pope Innocent III informs the archbishop of Tyre that the doge of Venice has complained that the archbishop has refused to accept the decision of an appeal in relation to the church of St Mark in Tyre. The pope has ordered the patriarch of Jerusalem and Cardinal P. of St Marcellus, the papal legates, to investigate and send a report to him.
Aug. 3. Ferentino. Pope Innocent III informs the archbishop of Tyre that the doge of Venice has complained that the archbishop has refused to accept the decision of an appeal in relation to the church of St Mark in Tyre. The pope has ordered the patriarch of Jerusalem and Cardinal P. of St... more
sources: Innocent III, Die Register 9:246-7, no. 138 (RRH no. 814)
RRR: Council/ruling decisions/legislation
1786
year: 1218
initiator: Pope Honorius III
recipient: Cardinal Pelagius of Albano
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: May. 8. Rome. St Peter’s. Pope Honorius III orders Cardinal Pelagius of Albano, the papal legate, to bring the dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the Venetians over the church of St Mark in Tyre to an end.
May. 8. Rome. St Peter’s. Pope Honorius III orders Cardinal Pelagius of Albano, the papal legate, to bring the dispute between the archbishop of Tyre and the Venetians over the church of St Mark in Tyre to an end.
sources: Claverie, Honorius, pp. 329-30, no. 30 (RRH no. 910)
RRR: Council/ruling decisions/legislation
1810
year: 1218
initiator: Cardinal Pelagius of Albano, the papal legate
recipient: Episcopus Mantuanus and the abbas Montis Syon
institution: Saint Mark in Tyre
text: Nov. 25. In the siege camp at Damietta. Cardinal Pelagius of Albano, the papal legate, writes to the episcopus Mantuanus and the abbas Montis Syon, who are in Acre, committing to them judgement in the case between S. Tyrensis archiepiscopus and the Venetians over the church of St Mark in Tyre.
Nov. 25. In the siege camp at Damietta. Cardinal Pelagius of Albano, the papal legate, writes to the episcopus Mantuanus and the abbas Montis Syon, who are in Acre, committing to them judgement in the case between S. Tyrensis archiepiscopus and the Venetians over the church of St Mark in Tyre.
sources: Rey, ‘Chartes de l’abbaye du Mont-Sion’, pp. 54-5 (RRH no. 916)